OnPay offers flat-rate, full-service payroll with strong support for specialty industries — agriculture, restaurants, nonprofits, and clergy.
OnPay is a flat-fee payroll provider that competes head-on with Gusto, with deeper specialty industry support (farm payroll Form 943, clergy housing allowances, restaurant tipped wages, nonprofit 501(c)(3) tax exemptions). Benefits administration and HR tools are included.
Aggregated from verified user reviews on G2, Capterra, Trustpilot, and GetApp. Refreshed quarterly.
"OnPay handles our farm payroll including Form 943 without a second thought. None of the bigger names supported it as cleanly."
"One flat price for everything — benefits, payroll, HR. No upsells, no surprises."
"Brand is smaller than Gusto but the product is on par or better, and pricing is identical. Worth a serious look."
Start a free trial and see if OnPay fits your workflow. No credit card required for most plans.
Same price point. OnPay wins on specialty industry support and simplicity; Gusto wins on brand, ecosystem, and modern UX.
Answer 10 questions about your ERP, team size, and processes. We'll match you with the right vendors and send a tailored shortlist.